Why Do Two People Pay Different Prices for the Same Health Insurance?
Two coworkers sit in the same office, do the same job, and decide to get supplemental health insurance. One pays 180 euros a year, the other 340. The policies sound almost identical. So what’s going on here?
Someone looking for a quote for the first time usually expects a single, clear figure. But health insurance pricing doesn’t work that way—it’s determined by several factors that are tailored to each individual. Insurers don’t publicly disclose their rates, and the standard phrase “it depends on your needs” doesn’t really explain anything.
Below, we’ll explain what actually determines the final cost and why the cheapest option isn’t always the smartest.
In ShortThe cost of private health insurance is primarily determined by three factors: age and health status, coverage scope, and the deductible (your copayment). A typical annual policy costs between approximately 150 and 450 euros per person. Don’t choose based solely on the lowest price—what the policy actually covers is what matters.
Why There Is No Single “Right” Price
Health insurance isn’t a product with a price tag. The insurer assesses the risk: what’s the likelihood that they’ll have to pay out to you, and how much. The higher the anticipated risk, the more expensive the policy.
That’s exactly why the price for two people can differ by a factor of two, even if at first glance they’ve chosen “the same” insurance.
The point is simple. You’re not paying for the name on the policy, but for the specific scope of coverage and your risk profile.
~150–250 €/year
Typical price of a basic policy
~300–450 €/year
Policy with broader coverage
Price differences between insurers can be significant
Price differences among insurers for a similar package
Three main factors that determine the price
1. Age and health status
Age is probably the strongest factor affecting price. Statistically, a 28-year-old is less likely to seek medical treatment than a 58-year-old, so their policy will cost less.
The difference in cost between a younger and an older person for identical coverage can be significant. Some insurers use age groups (e.g., up to 35, 36–50, 51+), each with its own rate.
Health status is also important. Some insurers require you to fill out a health declaration. Existing chronic conditions may result in either a higher premium or the exclusion of certain conditions from coverage (an exclusion). Simply put, the healthier and younger you are when you take out the policy, the more favorable the rate will be for you.
2. Scope of Coverage
This is where the greatest confusion lies. Two policies may both be called “health insurance,” but they may cover completely different things.
The basic package often covers outpatient consultations, tests, and medications up to a certain amount. A more comprehensive plan additionally covers rehabilitation, dental care, surgeries, treatment at private clinics without waiting lists, or even counseling sessions with a psychologist.
Information: Always check the coverage limit—the maximum amount the insurer will pay out per year. A policy for €160 with an annual limit of €1,000 and a policy for €320 with a limit of €3,000 are not the same product, even if they share the same name.
The broader the coverage and the higher the coverage limit, the more you pay. It’s logical, but this is often overlooked when two numbers are listed side by side.
3. Deductible and Your Premium
An deductible is the portion of the costs you pay yourself before insurance coverage kicks in. In health insurance, it’s often a percentage or a fixed amount for each service.
The logic is this: the higher the deductible you agree to pay yourself, the lower your annual premium will be. And vice versa.
For example, a policy with a 20% deductible will cost less than a “no-deductible” option. But for a €60 consultation with a 20% deductible, you’ll pay €12 out of pocket. So a lower annual premium doesn’t always mean lower overall costs.
The cheapest policy is the most expensive when you need it, if it doesn’t cover what you’re seeking treatment for.
A Specific Calculation Example
Let’s look at two hypothetical people comparing quotes for 2026.
| Profile | Jonas, 30 years old | Rūta, 52 |
|---|
| Age group | Up to 35 | 51+ |
| Scope of Coverage | Basic (outpatient care, tests) | Extended (+ rehabilitation, dental care) |
| Insurance coverage/year | €1,500 | €3,000 |
| Deductible | 15% | 0% |
| Health Declaration | No remarks | Chronic condition |
| Annual cost (example) | ~165 € | ~390 € |
Both have “health insurance.” But Jon’s policy is cheaper because he is younger, has narrower coverage, and a higher deductible. Rūta’s is more expensive because of her age, broader coverage, and the fact that she doesn’t want to pay extra for every visit.
Price breakdown by factors (example): - Impact of age: significant - Scope of coverage: significant - Choice of deductible: significant
The most common mistake is choosing based solely on price
Many people compare several offers, find the lowest price, and sign up. But six months later, it turns out that rehabilitation after an injury isn’t covered, and dental care is limited to just 50 €.
The lowest price usually means one of three things: limited coverage, a low insured amount, or a high deductible. Often, it’s all three at once.
Warning: Before signing, ask yourself three questions: 1
. What exactly does this policy cover, and what does it not cover?
2. What is the maximum annual coverage limit?
3. How much will I have to pay out of pocket for a typical visit or test (deductible)?
If you don’t know the answers, the price doesn’t mean anything to you yet.
There’s also the opposite mistake—overpaying for coverage you’ll never use. For a young, healthy person, a comprehensive plan that includes dental care and rehabilitation may simply be unnecessary if they only need a few consultations a year.
How to Choose Wisely
Start with your needs, not the price. Think about why you want insurance in the first place: to avoid waiting lists, cover dental care, have protection in case of a serious illness, or simply see a specialist faster.
Then compare not just a single figure, but the entire package—the coverage amount, deductible, exclusions, and covered services—side by side.
This is exactly where price comparison tools come in handy. Instead of calling each insurer separately, Draudykle.lt lets you view offers from several of Lithuania’s most popular insurers in one place, compare not only prices but also deductibles and the scope of coverage, and if you have any questions, consult with an insurance advisor in Lithuanian at any time of day. It’s convenient that you can purchase insurance immediately online, without any phone calls or visits.
Such a simple comparison often reveals that you can get broader coverage from another company for a similar or even lower price.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does health insurance cost per person? Depending on age, coverage, and deductible, the typical annual cost usually ranges from about 150 to 450 euros. For a younger person with a basic plan, the cost is closer to the lower end of the range; for an older person with comprehensive coverage, it’s closer to the upper end. This is just a rough estimate; the final amount is calculated on an individual basis.
Does the cost of private health insurance change every year? Yes, it can change. When renewing a policy, the premium is often recalculated based on a new age group or updated rates. When you move into a new age group, the premium usually increases slightly. Health insurance in 2026 may cost you a little differently than it did a few years ago.
Why don’t insurers publish their prices publicly? Because the final amount depends on your individual details—your age, the coverage you’ve chosen, your deductible, and sometimes your health declaration. There simply isn’t a single fixed number, so the price is only visible after entering specific details.
Is it worth choosing a higher deductible to lower my premium? It depends on how often you plan to use the services. If you seek care infrequently, a higher deductible and a lower annual premium may be worth it. If you visit frequently, a lower deductible often works out cheaper overall, since you’ll pay less per visit.
Can I get insurance if I have a chronic condition? Usually yes, but that specific condition may be excluded or result in a higher premium. Terms vary by insurer, so it’s worth comparing several offers.
A Brief Conclusion
Two people pay different amounts for “the same” health insurance because, in reality, they aren’t buying the same thing. Age, coverage scope, and deductible vary—these three factors account for almost the entire price difference.
Don’t judge a policy based solely on the lowest price. Look at what it actually covers, the coverage amount, and how much you’ll have to pay out of pocket. Only then does the price make sense.
Compare insurance prices in just a few minutes
Draudykle.lt will help you compare offers from the most popular Lithuanian insurers and purchase insurance online.
Compare prices →